Facebook Twitter Google +1     Admin

Vanity Fea

Powered by Rollyo

Arguing with a libertarian

domingo, 12 de mayo de 2013

Arguing with a libertarian

I've been arguing with a libertarian who does not believe in state coertion but thinks, anyway, that dangerous criminals should be punished through a system of voluntary associations freely entered into...:

Ricky, your plan for voluntary association vs. aggression etc. sounds very much like "choose your own Protection". That phase of human history was dealt with c. 4,000 years BC, and the outcome was (guess what) the appearance of the State and the state monopoly of coertion. Because otherwise there's the trouble of deciding a) who is a dangerous criminal and b) who should lock him up. That sounds like the band of Protectors with the bigger guns and most coercive power will set the rules. And that's what we have got — so everyone's happy and we agree deep down. Deep, deep down.

This is from a LinkedIn conversation, btw.

Viernes, 07 de Junio de 2013 12:56. José Ángel García Landa Enlace permanente. Política

Comentarios » Ir a formulario

Blog de notas de
José Ángel García Landa

(Biescas y Zaragoza)
"Algo hay en el formato mismo de los blogs que estimula un desarrollo casi canceroso de nuestro ego"
(John Hiler)





Blog creado con Blogia. Esta web utiliza cookies para adaptarse a tus preferencias y analítica web.
Blogia apoya a la Fundación Josep Carreras.

Contrato Coloriuris